Uploaded image for project: 'Contrib: Gradebook2'
  1. Contrib: Gradebook2
  2. GRBK-702

The statistics view needs to handle grades that are greater than 100%

    Details

    • Type: Bug Bug
    • Status: Closed
    • Priority: Major Major
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Affects Version/s: 1.3.0
    • Fix Version/s: 1.4.0-a1
    • Component/s: Services
    • Labels:
      None
    • Target Version:
    • QA Status:
      PASS
    • Previous Issue Keys:

      Description

      Functional Description: Modify the Statistics display to enable graphical display of grades over 100% that feed to the gradebook from the Tests & Quizzes tool.

      The statistics view needs to handle grades that are greater than 100%. e.g. Samigo can create grades per assignment that are greater than 100%

        Gliffy Diagrams

        1. GRBK-702.patch
          3 kB
          Thomas Amsler
        1. GRBK-702-1.png
          120 kB
        2. GRBK-702-2.png
          56 kB

          Issue Links

            Activity

            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment -

            Created patch since we wait until trunk becomes 1.4.0

            TODO: Apply patch to trunk

            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - Created patch since we wait until trunk becomes 1.4.0 TODO: Apply patch to trunk
            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment -

            Committed patch in trunk @ r69955

            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - Committed patch in trunk @ r69955
            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment -

            QA Testing:

            • Use Samigo to create an assignment where a student receives a score that is greater than 100%
            • Once the Samigo course grade has been transfered to gardebook2, open the statistics view and click on the grade item for which we have at least one 100%+ score.
            • See attached screen captures for more information.
            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - QA Testing: Use Samigo to create an assignment where a student receives a score that is greater than 100% Once the Samigo course grade has been transfered to gardebook2, open the statistics view and click on the grade item for which we have at least one 100%+ score. See attached screen captures for more information.
            Hide
            nancy wilkison added a comment -

            SmartSite@UCDavis - 2.6.4.2 - Sakai 2.6.2 - Server "ucddev1"
            This instance is running gradebook2 v1.4.0-a4

            firefox as IOR, ie8 as students
            site AAA 123 123 su10, if you want to look.
            TEST PLAN (abbreviated)
            1 - created t&q associated w/gb2
            2 - took it as student, verified score in t&qn gb and statistics page - ok
            3 - ADJ score in t&q to >100%
            4 - re-checked new score everywhere, as IOR and student - ok, no errors
            5 - took as another student w/<100% score (B grade in gb2), checked grades everywhere
            6 - here's where I have a problem. on view-statistics page, I don't get an error on the page or
            with the graph. BUT the mean and median show as A+...which I have a problem with. I
            don't think the mean of A+ + B should be A+. or is it being calculated on points, even if
            there is an overage? so (133 + 62)/2=97.5, which is an A+. I'd expect mean and median to
            be calculated on a max of 100...but that's just me.

            RESULTS -
            not sure
            I didn't get an error message for >100% score on the statistics page, which would be a PASS.
            BUT see 6 above.
            or is this another issue? I don't know what to expect it to do.............

            Show
            nancy wilkison added a comment - SmartSite@UCDavis - 2.6.4.2 - Sakai 2.6.2 - Server "ucddev1" This instance is running gradebook2 v1.4.0-a4 firefox as IOR, ie8 as students site AAA 123 123 su10, if you want to look. TEST PLAN (abbreviated) 1 - created t&q associated w/gb2 2 - took it as student, verified score in t&qn gb and statistics page - ok 3 - ADJ score in t&q to >100% 4 - re-checked new score everywhere, as IOR and student - ok, no errors 5 - took as another student w/<100% score (B grade in gb2), checked grades everywhere 6 - here's where I have a problem. on view-statistics page, I don't get an error on the page or with the graph. BUT the mean and median show as A+...which I have a problem with. I don't think the mean of A+ + B should be A+. or is it being calculated on points, even if there is an overage? so (133 + 62)/2=97.5, which is an A+. I'd expect mean and median to be calculated on a max of 100...but that's just me. RESULTS - not sure I didn't get an error message for >100% score on the statistics page, which would be a PASS. BUT see 6 above. or is this another issue? I don't know what to expect it to do.............
            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment -

            We will further investigate Nancy's finding in the above step 6. This need to be brought up in sakai-dev.

            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - We will further investigate Nancy's finding in the above step 6. This need to be brought up in sakai-dev.
            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment -

            I have sent out an email to the Sakai community and UCD folks regarding this issue.

            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - I have sent out an email to the Sakai community and UCD folks regarding this issue.
            Hide
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - - edited

            I think this is a PASS. The potential issue that Nancy found is being discussed. I have created GRBK-809 to cover that part.

            Show
            Thomas Amsler added a comment - - edited I think this is a PASS. The potential issue that Nancy found is being discussed. I have created GRBK-809 to cover that part.
            Hide
            Joyce Johnstone added a comment -

            NANCY - Can you add a comment to confirm the QA PASS and then THOMAS can you close this?

            Thanks,
            JOYCE

            Show
            Joyce Johnstone added a comment - NANCY - Can you add a comment to confirm the QA PASS and then THOMAS can you close this? Thanks, JOYCE
            Hide
            Nancy Wilkison added a comment -

            ok...to make everyone happy I'll PASS this.
            since the issue I had with it is being addressed.

            Show
            Nancy Wilkison added a comment - ok...to make everyone happy I'll PASS this. since the issue I had with it is being addressed.

              People

              • Assignee:
                Unassigned
                Reporter:
                Thomas Amsler
              • Votes:
                0 Vote for this issue
                Watchers:
                1 Start watching this issue

                Dates

                • Created:
                  Updated:
                  Resolved: