Uploaded image for project: 'Sakai'
  1. Sakai
  2. SAK-41328

Samigo > Interim solution for SAK-34222

    XMLWordPrintable

    Details

    • 19 status:
      Verified
    • Test Plan:
      Hide
      1. Add a Multiple Choice question to a test.
      2. Select Multiple Correct, Multiple Selection and All or Nothing for the correct answer option.
      3. Enter some text for the question and create several correct answers.
      4. Save the test.
      5. In Working Copies, select Export from the drop-down for the test. Verify the presence of the following text:

        Important: Tests that contain Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions with All or Nothing selected do not retain this setting on import to another site. To remedy this, after import, edit these questions before publishing to reset the selection back to All or Nothing.

      6. Select Import to import the exported copy, and verify presence of the following text on the import screen:

        Important: Tests that contain Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions with All or Nothing selected do not retain this setting on import to another site. To remedy this, after import, edit these questions before publishing to reset the selection back to All or Nothing.

      7. Edit this new copy (check your multiple choice question).
      8. Note that the question's correct answer option has changed to Correct minus Incorrect.
      Show
      Add a Multiple Choice question to a test. Select Multiple Correct, Multiple Selection and All or Nothing for the correct answer option. Enter some text for the question and create several correct answers. Save the test. In Working Copies , select Export from the drop-down for the test. Verify the presence of the following text: Important: Tests that contain Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions with All or Nothing selected do not retain this setting on import to another site. To remedy this, after import, edit these questions before publishing to reset the selection back to All or Nothing . Select Import to import the exported copy, and verify presence of the following text on the import screen: Important: Tests that contain Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions with All or Nothing selected do not retain this setting on import to another site. To remedy this, after import, edit these questions before publishing to reset the selection back to All or Nothing . Edit this new copy (check your multiple choice question). Note that the question's correct answer option has changed to Correct minus Incorrect .

      Description

      There is currently a bug in Samigo where if you have a quiz which contains any Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions that are set to require All or Nothing to get the question correct, exporting and importing this quiz into further sites will not retain the All or Nothing setting. The resulting imports will have changed this setting to Correct minus Incorrect without the user realizing it.

      This is a usability issue for instructors, and can affect grading of students if the instructors don't fully vet each imported quiz before publishing. This bug is captured in SAK-34222, and seems to be a deficiency in the export file produced.

      In the interim, this PR proposes to add warnings in the UIs so that the instructor is aware of this up front:

      Important: Tests that contain Multiple Choice, Multiple Selection questions with All or Nothing selected do not retain this setting on import to another site. To remedy this, after import, edit these questions before publishing to reset the selection back to All or Nothing.

      When a proper solution is implemented for SAK-34222, it should also revert the changes introduced here.

        Gliffy Diagrams

          Attachments

          1. 03192019_export_text.gif
            03192019_export_text.gif
            16 kB
          2. 03192019_import_text.gif
            03192019_import_text.gif
            15 kB
          3. bulletList.png
            bulletList.png
            97 kB
          4. oneMessage.png
            oneMessage.png
            86 kB
          5. twoMessages1.png
            twoMessages1.png
            86 kB
          6. twoMessages2.png
            twoMessages2.png
            87 kB

            Issue Links

              Activity

                People

                • Assignee:
                  bjones86 Brian Jones
                  Reporter:
                  bjones86 Brian Jones
                • Votes:
                  0 Vote for this issue
                  Watchers:
                  8 Start watching this issue

                  Dates

                  • Created:
                    Updated:
                    Resolved:

                    Git Source Code